1. Entertainment

Discuss in my forum

'Whiteout' Movie Review

About.com Rating 2 Star Rating
Be the first to write a review

By , About.com Guide

'Whiteout' movie poster © Warner Bros.
Like real estate, the secret to a movie's success can sometimes be all about location, location, location. Want to spice up a tired old script? Change the setting to an underwater maximum-security prison, a rotating space station made precariously of Zima bottles or, in the case of Whiteout, Antarctica.

The Plot

Carrie Stetko (Kate Beckinsale) is the only US Marshall assigned to Antarctica. Her days are filled with monotonous tasks, but ever diligent, she investigates every petty squabble and crime. In fact, due to the emotional scars from a traumatic event in her law enforcement past, she's happy to now be little more than a babysitter for the 200 or so researchers, pilots and other workers at the Amundsen-Scott South Pole Station.

Her peaceful bliss is shattered, however, when someone spots a body on the ice. Heading out to investigate with pilot Delfy (Columbus Short), Carrie finds the remains of a geologist nowhere near where he was supposed to be. She takes the body back to the base for Doc Fury (Tom Skerritt) to autopsy, and it becomes apparent that this was no boating accident. The scientist was murdered.

Carrie's investigation leads her from witness to witness and into a face-to-face encounter with the killer -- or rather, face to mask, as the culprit is clad from head to toe in snow garb. She's soon joined by Robert Pryce (Gabriel Macht), a United Nations representative seeking to solve the case in order to avoid an international incident. With her uneasy alliance, Carrie delves deeper into the mystery, discovering ties to a Russian plane that disappeared more than 50 years ago. But time is short, and if they don't solve the crime before the last air lift leaves in two days, winter will set in, and they'll be forced to stay at the base through six months of sun-less snow.

The End Result

Kate Beckinsale in 'Whiteout'.

Kate Beckinsale in 'Whiteout'.

© Warner Bros.
The breathtaking snowy expanses of the Antarctic setting (actually filmed in Canada) and the intriguing concept of the continent's first murder might tempt you into thinking that Whiteout is a unique cinematic experience, but it turns out to be a very ordinary tale set in an extraordinary location. In fact, as Hollywood murder mysteries go, it's excruciatingly by the book. Burned-out cop haunted by a tragic past? Check. Forced "buddy cop" partnership? Check. Paranoid informants who can't be bothered to spit out the killer's name before dying? Check. A killer who's everywhere at once yet becomes clumsy only when it's time to kill the hero? Check. Drawn-out explanations that serve only to provide good clips in TV ads (e.g., "We found something in the ice," or "I told them not to trust him.")? Check. Big reveal of a killer whom the audience has suspected all along? Check and mate.

I haven't read the graphic novel upon which it's based, but I imagine (read: hope) that its contents have been butchered by the two pairs of screenwriters who worked on Whiteout. They desperately want us to believe that the story is fresh, interesting and complex, but instead they deliver a tale that's shallow and predictable, attempting to cover up its deficiencies with blizzards and body parts. Hey, look what minus-120-degree weather can do to human skin! (Footsteps running away, tires squealing.)

Apart from the snowy surroundings, everything about Whiteout is about as fresh as an episode of Quincy, with "twists" that have been seen countless times before and are guessable from the opening scenes. The sleuthing process of the central characters is perfunctory at best -- something like CSI: Antarctica -- and at worst lazily executed, skimming over any semblance of investigative process. This is the type of movie where the hero has "a bad feeling" or an illogical hunch that always turns out to be correct. Carrie walks in on a 50-year-old, frosted-over crime scene and immediately breaks down what happened with head-spinning jumps in logic. I would say that the writers didn't want to bog the story down, but then they toss in a 10-minute sequence about an avalanche that serves no purpose plot-wise, nor does it convey any drama, tension or thrills.

It's no surprise that director Dominic Sena, best known for Swordfish and Gone in 60 Seconds, is at his best during action sequences, which pop with an energy that hints at the movie's potential. The other scenes, though, have no emotional impact, and scares are non-existent as Sena struggles to figure out if he's directing action, horror or mystery. He ends up delivering precious little of any of the three, feeding into the unintentional camp of the dialogue with his workmanlike storytelling and overabundance of lazy flashbacks. If it weren't bad enough that the plot is dumbed down into a string of cliches, it's then spoon-fed to the audience with flashback after flashback after -- wait for it -- flashback.

Gabriel Macht and Columbus Short in 'Whiteout'.

Gabriel Macht and Kate Beckingsale in 'Whiteout'.

© Warner Bros.

Beckinsale is a likable heroine who has displayed her abundant physicality in the Underworld series, but in Whiteout, she's reduced to fleeing, fumbling around in the snow and reciting hammy dialogue that more than once drew laughs from the audience I was in. At least some people got a kick out of it.

Related Video
Dominic Sena Interview - Whiteout Movie
Greg Rucka Interview - Whiteout

©2013 About.com. All rights reserved.