1. Entertainment

Discuss in my forum

'New Moon' Movie Review

About.com Rating 2.5 Star Rating
Be the first to write a review

By , About.com Guide

'New Moon' movie poster.© Summit
So, there's this little thing called Twilight; maybe you've heard of it? The successful series of young adult books has now turned into an even more successful series of films that's become the 21st century's equivalent of the Star Wars franchise for pre-teen girls. Its rabid fan base makes reviews like this of New Moon, the second in the series, pretty much moot, but here I go.

The Plot

When we left Twilight, tasty human Bella (Kristen Stewart) had been accepted into the Cullen clan of vampires, having hooked up with Edward (Robert Pattinson), a hundred-year-old vamp with teenage heartthrob looks. Now, as we pick things up, the Cullens are throwing her an 18th birthday celebration that goes awry when a paper cut triggers the family's bloodlust.

Taking this near feeding frenzy as a sign that Bella isn't safe around them, the Cullens decide to pack up and move out of town. Heartbroken, she mopes -- even more than usual -- for months before discovering that she can "see" Edward by doing something dangerous. It seems that motorcycle riding or cliff diving conjures up Obi-Wan-like visions of him warning her to be careful, like a motherly ghost with dreamboat hair.

Bella seeks the aid of old pal Jacob (Taylor Lautner) to help her repair an old motorcycle that she can use for her hallucinatory thrills, and having had a crush on her for some time, Jacob readily agrees. During the weeks-long repair process, Bella grows closer to Jacob, in part because he's become physically buff since she last saw him and in part because, well, he's there.

It turns out that Jacob's physical metamorphosis -- including an increasingly volatile temper -- is emblematic of a bigger change: he's a werewolf. And, like her vampire ex-boyfriend, Jacob pushes her away when he fears for her safety.

Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson in 'New Moon'.

Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson in 'New Moon'.

© Summit

Luckily for Bella, she still has her life-threatening stunts to fall back on, but when one results in her near-death, Edward misinterprets a long-distance message to mean that she's dead. With the wisdom of a teenager, he determines to end his life too by going to the Volturi, the Italian vampire royalty who oversee the actions of their kind worldwide. Can Bella clear things up before he pulls a Romeo? And who will she ultimately choose: Edward or Jacob?

The End Result

New Moon is a step up from Twilight, which is quite a feat given the limitations placed on it by its source material. The story constructed by author Stephenie Meyer is dull, illogical and ludicrous, and yet screenwriter Melissa Rosenberg and director Chris Weitz manage to render the plot watchable and, despite being 15 or 20 minutes too long, rarely tedious.

Part of the success comes courtesy of a sense of humor largely absent in the first movie. Whereas Twilight, as the introductory film in the series, was more concerned with establishing the characters, New Moon has more freedom to play with relationships and dole out "in jokes." Rosenberg's dialogue has some refreshingly light moments that make Bella's perpetually gloomy character seem almost human, while Weitz's direction often seems tongue-in-cheek and self-consciously campy, packed with the rampant shirtlessness (and in one scene, near pantslessness) designed to make the theater erupt in squeals.

Another aspect that makes New Moon more enjoyable than Twilight is unintentional. The bland, emotionless Edward-Bella relationship that dominated the first film takes a back seat here to more intriguing storylines, from the werewolf pack recruiting Jacob to the Volturi introduction to the return of vampire baddies from the previous movie to a Jacob-Bella relationship that doesn't subject us to quite as much Harlequin melodrama.

Taylor Lautner and Kristen Stewart in 'New Moon'.

Taylor Lautner and Kristen Stewart in 'New Moon'.

© Summit

That said, New Moon is shallow, unrepentantly silly and worst of all, it sends a dangerous message to young girls about self-esteem (or lack thereof), the control that boys have over their lives and the extreme lengths to which girls should go to win love.

©2012 About.com. All rights reserved.

A part of The New York Times Company.