Here are my choices for the 40 best small releases of the 2012, which either showed in a limited number of theaters this year or went straight to home video. (For the purposes of this list, I'm defining "limited" as less than 500 screens.)
Honorable Mentions: Chained, The Day, Scary or Die, Death and Cremation, Caught Inside, Truth or Die, Devil Seed, Enter Nowhere, The Road, Baby Shower, The Fields, The Frozen.
40. Bait 3D
A shallow but fun, gory and well-shot sharks-in-a-store flick that SyFy movies of the week should view as inspiration.
39. Rosewood Lane
It's a real testament to Victor Salva's dazzlingly cinematic directorial prowess that he can make such a flawed movie -- ridiculous concept (psycho paperboy terrorizes neighborhood), gaping plot holes, nonsensical character actions, a "boy" who's clearly pushing 30 years old -- so fascinating to watch. (Granted, part of the fascination is due to the awe of watching such a silly film.) Salva (Jeepers Creepers) shows he still has the chops and delivers perhaps his best effort in taking his own whacked-out script and making it appreciably creepy.
38. Solomon Kane
Nothing groundbreaking or earth-shattering, but this supernatural medieval tale is dark, violent and visually striking with a flair for drama.
37. DeadHeads
A fun and breezy zombie comedy that's well written with wacky characters and a likable cast.
36. 388 Arletta Avenue
A clever and captivating utilization of the "found footage" format that presents all of its action through the lens of the stalker's cameras, resulting in some suprisingly seamless storytelling that balances the unpolished style of found footage with refined cinematic thrills.
35. Resurrection County
This surprisingly effective low-budget backwoods survival thriller stands out from most of its ilk with strong performances, a dramatic sense of realism (read: no inbred mutant cannibals) and rounded villains who aren't universally merciless and evil. A lot more horror fans would've liked Kevin Smith's Red State if it had channeled Resurrection County.
34. Penumbra
A well-made, involving little thriller from Argentina whose appeal lies in its upredictability and an impending sense of doom that builds as the audience perceives that something sinister is afoot.
33. Smiley
A surprisingly and refreshingly introspective take on the slasher sub-genre that explores the nihilism of humanity as expressed through juvenile Internet hijinks.
32. Excision
I don't know if I even like this movie all that much, but I admire its ballsiness, visual style and morbid humor. It's perhaps the darkest, most disturbing film of the year, like a coming-of-age comedy mixed with a necrophiliac serial killer's wet dream, mixing graphic violence and sexuality in an icky, can't-turn-away spectacle.
31. Red Lights
An ambitious and smartly conceived X-Files-ian look at the nature of belief with a dynamite cast and a nice twist ending.












