The End Result
The writing from Wayans and his collaborators is lazy, derivative and never fails to go for the easiest -- and usually most base -- punchline. Sure, spoof movies are generally low-brow, hardly cutting-edge affairs, but Scary Movie and the classics from David Zucker stayed on the right side of that fine line between playfully crude and numbingly crass. A Haunted House, on the other hand, stomps all over the line like a drunk failing a sobriety test. The fact that it's filled with sexual and potty humor isn't nearly as troubling as how poorly written that humor is. And when it's not well-written, the ugliness of the subject matter is magnified, from racism to misogyny, homophobia, child and spousal abuse and rape -- all are fair game here.
The crude racial stereotypes that were mined for some comedic gold in Wayans' 1996 urban drama spoof Don't Be a Menace to South Central While Drinking Your Juice in the Hood are now stale, but that doesn't stop him from mining that same tired vein. You'd think the 40-year-old would have something new or more refined to say by now, but apparently not. Wayans can be an effective comedic actor when reined in by a script that shows some level of subtlety or restraint, but that isn't A Haunted House. Instead, he attacks every punchline with a sledgehammer, mugging for the camera and beating dead horse gags even deader. If you're someone who finds him hilarious in anything he does, 1) this movie is for you, and 2) you need higher standards. It's no coincidence that the funniest (though still not particularly funny) moments in the film come from the accomplished supporting cast of comedy veterans -- namely, Cedric the Entertainer, Essence Atkins, J.B. Smoove and Affion Crockett.
- Acting: D (Wayans is grating and overblown; although the rest of the cast is strong, some seem embarrassed to be affiliated with this garbage.)
- Direction: D+ (I'm not sure what the director could've done to overcome the awfulness of the script, but he definitely doesn't do it.)
- Script: F (I wish I could give it a "G".)
- Gore/Effects: C- (No gore; modest effects.)
- Overall: D- (A lazy, puerile, scatological, juvenile assault on brain cells.)
A Haunted House is directed by Michael Tiddes and is rated R by the MPAA for crude and sexual content, language and some drug use. Release date: January 11, 2013.